The Argentine defender criticized United’s transfer strategy after a 2-0 Champions League loss, while manager Michael Carrick called for unity amid the club’s five-match winless streak.
Manchester United defender Lisandro Martinez has publicly criticized the club’s leadership following a 2-0 defeat to Atletico Madrid in the UEFA Champions League on October 13, 2026. The Argentine international questioned United’s summer transfer activity and called for greater investment after another disappointing performance under manager Michael Carrick.
Martinez directed much of his frustration toward the club’s hierarchy, including director of football Jason Wilcox. He argued that repeatedly changing managers would not solve United’s problems unless those responsible for recruitment and squad development also accepted responsibility.
The defeat at Atletico’s Riyadh Air Metropolitano stadium extended United’s winless streak to five matches in all competitions. It also increased pressure on Carrick, whose side has struggled to match expectations after qualifying for the Champions League last season.
Martinez Questions Manchester United’s Transfer Strategy
Speaking to Amazon Prime after the match, Martinez said he expected more support from the club’s decision-makers. He believed United had failed to strengthen their squad sufficiently after finishing third in the Premier League during the previous campaign.
The defender specifically questioned whether the club had done enough to help Carrick compete against stronger opponents in European football.
According to Reuters, Martinez said he expected more from the technical director while acknowledging that the players also needed to improve. His criticism focused on the balance between responsibility on the pitch and decisions made by senior officials.
Martinez argued that replacing coaches without addressing weaknesses elsewhere in the organization would do little to produce lasting improvements.
United’s decision to strengthen selected positions during the summer transfer window has come under scrutiny as injuries and inconsistent performances have exposed weaknesses in the squad.
The club returned to the Champions League after a two-season absence, creating expectations that additional signings would help it compete against Europe’s strongest teams.
Martinez suggested that the level of investment had not matched those ambitions. His comments were particularly significant because they came from a senior player rather than a former footballer or outside commentator.
He also acknowledged that the squad needed to take responsibility for its performances. His remarks were not simply a demand for new signings but a criticism of how the club was being managed.
Atletico Madrid Takes Control of Champions League Clash
Manchester United’s problems began almost immediately against Atletico Madrid.
Pablo Barrios opened the scoring after just 53 seconds, finishing a move that exposed gaps in United’s defensive organization. Alex Baena created the opportunity, leaving the visitors trailing before they had settled into the match.
United gradually improved and created opportunities to equalize. Bryan Mbeumo threatened Atletico’s goal, while Bruno Fernandes also had chances to bring his team back into the contest.
Atletico goalkeeper Jan Oblak made important saves to preserve the Spanish side’s advantage.
The hosts continued to create problems through their movement, passing and ability to exploit space behind United’s defensive line.
United suffered another setback in the 74th minute when defender Leny Yoro was sent off following a challenge on Jonathan David. The referee reviewed the incident before showing the French defender a red card.
Ademola Lookman scored Atletico’s second goal in the 79th minute, taking advantage of a rebound after United goalkeeper Senne Lammens had made an initial save.
The result left United with three points in the Champions League league phase, earned through their earlier 4-0 victory over Sabah FK.
It also highlighted the team’s difficulties converting promising attacking opportunities into goals while maintaining defensive stability.
Michael Carrick Responds to Martinez’s Comments
Manchester United manager Michael Carrick was asked about Martinez’s criticism after the final whistle.
Carrick said he had not personally seen the interview and therefore did not want to comment directly on its contents. He acknowledged that players could become emotional following disappointing results.
Rather than publicly challenging Martinez, Carrick emphasized the importance of the squad remaining together during a difficult period.
The former United midfielder also admitted that the performance against Atletico had been inconsistent.
Carrick said his players struggled after conceding the early goal but gradually established more control as the match developed. However, the team failed to turn periods of possession into enough dangerous opportunities.
He also questioned the decision to send off Yoro, suggesting that the dismissal had affected United’s chances of recovering.
The manager acknowledged that tactical adjustments had produced mixed results. He believed United had opportunities to take something from the match but failed to make the most of them.
Carrick’s response reflected an attempt to maintain stability while facing criticism over the team’s results and direction.
The manager was appointed permanently after a successful interim period during the 2025–26 season.
Following Ruben Amorim’s departure in January, Carrick guided United to 12 victories in 17 matches and helped secure a third-place Premier League finish.
That achievement earned him a two-year contract, but the beginning of the new campaign has been considerably more difficult.
Wayne Rooney Criticizes Martinez’s Public Remarks
Martinez’s comments also attracted criticism from former Manchester United striker Wayne Rooney.
Rooney argued that the defender’s public attack on the club’s leadership was disrespectful to his teammates and risked creating further tension within the squad.
The former United captain acknowledged concerns about the club’s transfer decisions but questioned whether criticizing senior officials immediately after a defeat was the right approach.
Rooney also suggested that Martinez should focus on improving his own performances before publicly questioning others.
His response illustrated a disagreement over how players should express frustration when results fall below expectations.
Some supporters believe public criticism is necessary to hold decision-makers accountable. Others argue that disputes involving recruitment and club management should remain private to avoid damaging confidence.
Martinez’s position carries weight because he has experienced both successful periods and difficult campaigns since joining United from Ajax in 2022.
However, the defender’s statements do not establish that the club’s summer recruitment was solely responsible for its poor results.
Injuries, tactical decisions and individual performances have also contributed to United’s inconsistent start.
Bruno Fernandes Remains Central to United’s Attack
Captain Bruno Fernandes was among the players who struggled to convert opportunities against Atletico Madrid.
The Portuguese midfielder had chances to score but could not produce the equalizer United needed.
Despite those missed opportunities, Fernandes remains one of the team’s most influential attacking players.
He scored a hat-trick during United’s 5-2 victory over Ipswich Town in August, demonstrating his ability to change matches through goals and creativity.
Fernandes also played an important role in United’s strong finish to the previous season under Carrick.
His performances remain particularly important because the team continues to rely on his ability to create scoring opportunities.
There is no verified evidence that Martinez directed his post-match criticism at Fernandes or accused the captain of acting in his own interests.
The defender’s public complaints concerned the club’s leadership, recruitment decisions and the responsibilities shared by players and executives.
Pressure Mounts Ahead of Leeds United Match
United’s latest defeat adds to a difficult opening period in the 2026–27 campaign.
The club has recorded only two victories in its first nine competitive matches and sits 13th in the Premier League.
Those results represent a sharp reversal from the progress United made during Carrick’s initial spell in charge.
The team has struggled with defensive mistakes, missed scoring opportunities and inconsistent performances across domestic and European competitions.
Carrick must now prepare his players for another demanding fixture.
Manchester United will travel to Elland Road to face Leeds United on Sunday, October 18, before returning to Champions League action against Italian side Como on October 21.
The Leeds match offers United an opportunity to end its winless run and reduce the pressure surrounding the manager and his players.
It will also test how the squad responds following Martinez’s public criticism of the club’s leadership.
United’s immediate priority is improving results while addressing the concerns raised about recruitment and squad development. With another European fixture approaching, Carrick has limited time to restore confidence and demonstrate that his team can compete consistently.
IMAGE: Author Bryan Berlin Attribution (required by the license) Bryan Berlin / WikiPortraits CC4